News

Montgomery City’s Garage Sale Store 2.0 is gaining popularity

By Theo Tate, Managing editor
Posted 11/19/26

After almost two years, John Miller couldn’t have been any happier of his wife Kelley.

He is thrilled that Kelley is enjoying success as the owner of the Garage Sale Store 2.0, located at 213 …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in
News

Montgomery City’s Garage Sale Store 2.0 is gaining popularity

Posted

After almost two years, John Miller couldn’t have been any happier of his wife Kelley.

He is thrilled that Kelley is enjoying success as the owner of the Garage Sale Store 2.0, located at 213 Sturgeon. It has plenty of items such as clothes, jewelry, appliances and furniture and has become a popular spot in the Montgomery City business district.

“I’m very proud of her,” John said.

Kelley decided to become an entrepreneur when her husband started having health issues, including stomach cancer. John had cancer surgery in May 2024.

“After John had his cancer surgery and got his stomach removed, he wanted storage lockers,” Kelley said. “I was like, ‘OK, we can do storage lockers.’ So we did. I kind of liked it. We would set up flea markets and stuff. Then, this became available, so we decided to come here and get all of the stuff out of our house.”

The Garage Sale Store 2.0 was open for business on Dec. 31, 2024 at a spot that John was very familiar with. He operated the Garage Sale Store at the same location for 13 years before he decided to shut it down.

“I got divorced, so we closed it,” John said. “It sat empty for years. When I drove by it, I was always thinking, ‘I want to go back, I want to go back.’ I went into construction and I got diagnosed with cancer. We decided to take it to doing garage sales in our yard and flea markets. But it became too much on me. I had my stomach removed.”

Before Garage Sale Store 2.0 opened nearly two years ago, the building housed Your Hometown Resale Shop, which was owned by Jonesburg resident Steve Dosenbach. It opened in May 2020.

The closing of that store led to an opportunity for the Millers to reopen it as Garage Sale Store 2.0. Kelley, who lived in the Montgomery City area all of her life, worked as a nurse before she became Garage Sale Store 2.0.

“The main thing about it was that John wanted me to open the store so I could be my own boss, still do homeschool and make money,” Kelley said. “If he passed away, I would be financially stable. My whole thing was this is what he always loved to do. If he didn’t have a lot of time left, then this is what he should be doing. So, this is what we decided to do.”

Kelley said ever since the store opened 23 months ago, she has been seeing customers buy a wide variety of items.

“Everybody got their own little thing,” Kelley said. “We have people who come in just to buy DVDs. We have people who come in just to buy clothes. Sometimes, random people come in and just start throwing everything on the counter and finding random stuff. We had a lady come in probably 15 minutes before closing and she just walked through the store and she was like, ‘I want this, this, this and this.’”

The Garage Sale Store 2.0 is open from 11 a.m.-7 p.m. from Tuesday to Saturday.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here


X