News

Commission votes against increase in prosecuting attorney salary

By Theo Tate, Managing editor
Posted 11/20/26

The Montgomery County Commission voted unanimously to not raise the prosecuting attorney’s salary to 95 percent of the circuit judge’s salary.

County officials stated that the prosecuting …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in
News

Commission votes against increase in prosecuting attorney salary

Posted

The Montgomery County Commission voted unanimously to not raise the prosecuting attorney’s salary to 95 percent of the circuit judge’s salary.

County officials stated that the prosecuting attorney has been eligible for 100 percent of the associate circuit judge’s pay, but decided to reject the increase of the prosecuting attorney’s wages due to a newly passed legislation. The decision was reached in an unanimous vote by the commissioners in early October.

“They passed a bill at the very end of the legislative session that they were paid at the same level as the associate circuit judge right now,” 1st District Commissioner Dave Teeter said. “So every time the federal judges get raises, then that funnels down to the state judges, then it funnels down to (the sheriff’s) salary and the prosecuting attorney salary. They wanted to raise that again, but part of the bill allowed third-class counties to decide whether they wanted to keep it where it presently is, which is tied with the associate circuit judge, or to increase it to 95 percent of the circuit judge’s salary. We decided that at this point of the time, it needed to stay the same because he’s always going to get a raise.”

The prosecuting attorney is the highest paid elected official in Montgomery County at $167,833 without taxes. The average salary for a circuit judge is $170,237.

Paul Boyd is the current prosecuting attorney. He took over that position on Oct. 7, 2025, replacing Keith Freie.

Teeter said Boyd was informed about the final decision by county officials.

“It’s no reflection on the confidence that we have with our new prosecutor,” Teeter said. “I think he’s doing a darn good job.”

The prosecuting attorney became a full-time position in Montgomery County in 2018. That year, the prosecuting attorney’s salary was in the $37,000 salary range before it increased after residents voted to make it a full-time position.

Current Associate Circuit Judge Nathan Carroz worked as a part-time prosecuting attorney in 2018. He was making $37,637 that year. The following year, it jumped to $89,418 after he became full-time.

“He wasn’t working 20 hours,” Presiding Commissioner Ryan Poston said. “He was working 40-50 hours a week for $45,000 with a law degree.”

2nd District Commissioner Doug Lensing said a prosecuting attorney in Montgomery County is a position that requires a lot of work.

“The county has a major interstate highway through it,” he said. “It just multiplies the amount of things they have to prosecute with drugs and traffic violations. So we just got an extra load that a county of our size generally doesn’t have.”

In 2018, Poston and then-associate commissioners Rich Daniels and John Noltensmeyer decided to add the prosecuting attorney measure to the April general election ballot. Voters overwhelmingly approved it with 932 yes votes and 236 no votes.

“The county commission had to authorize it for a vote to let the voter decide if they wanted a full-time prosecuting attorney,” Poston said. “So we put it on the ballot and of course, everyone passed it.”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here


X